Willa Cather’s My Antonía was published in 1918, just two years before the 19th Amendment was ratified, giving women the right to vote. Suffrage plays a blink-if-you-miss-it role in My Antonía, too: In the framing introduction to the 1918 version, the narrator notes how Jim Burden’s wife, Genevieve Whitney, “gave one of her town houses for a suffrage headquarters.” What’s more, Genevieve “produced one of her own plays at the Princess Theater,” “was arrested for picketing during a garment-maker’s strike”, and played “patroness to a group of young poets of advanced ideas and mediocre ability.” (I suspect Cather shared some of the narrator’s delightful crankiness.)
The narrator “dislikes” Genevieve, but not due to politics. He doesn’t reveal what he thinks of universal suffrage, labor unions, or any of the progressive movements of the time. He does, however, offer his caustic opinion that he doubts Genevieve “has much feeling for the causes to which she lends her name and fleeting interest.” Her dabbling in activism and art, he implies, is more to gain attention and progressive street-cred. In other words, it’s performative.
As such, Genevieve (or at least the Genevieve the narrator perceives) is the perfect foil to Antonía Shimerda, the novel’s heroine and the subject of Jim’s reminiscence. Genevieve adopts and casts off causes like fashions, trying on identities and changing them with the season. In contrast, Antonía doesn’t wear identities, she simply lives. She doesn’t perform, she simply is.
That “anti-performative” quality is at the heart of the feminism of My Antonía. Antonía and other female characters buck convention, to be sure, but not to stick it to the Patriarchy, or to signal their allegiance to a political or identitarian tribe. They’re simply living authentically, in accordance with their natures — in Antonía’s case, a profoundly creative one.
Antonía: The Anti-Performative Generator
Antonía deviates from traditional female norms via the raw physical strength she displays in performing farm work. But she deviates from modern, liberal female norms, too — most notably through her fertility, through how she tends, nurtures, and brings to fruition.
It’s a power Jim frames in mythic terms. When Antonia’s eleven children run outside from an underground cellar, he describes them as “a veritable explosion of life.” What’s more, he suggests Antonia’s life-giving and life-sustaining power makes her something of a prophet, one who illuminates the hidden nature of reality:
She still had that something which fires the imagination, could still stop one's breath for a moment by a look or gesture that somehow revealed the meaning in common things. She had only to stand in the orchard, to put her hand on a little crab tree and look up at the apples, to make you feel the goodness of planting and tending and harvesting at last. All the strong things of her heart came out in her body, that had been so tireless in serving generous emotions. It was no wonder that her sons stood tall and straight. She was a rich mine of life, like the founders of early races.
Modern feminism frames motherhood as a “choice” women can elect in exercising their reproductive freedom. But as the foregoing passage illustrates, Antonía doesn’t “choose” motherhood; she is motherhood, a generative force of nature down to her very being. She transcends the idea of motherhood as the exercise of personal autonomy.
Nowhere is this more evident than in her treatment of her illegitimate child. When Jim visits home, he discovers a crayon enlargement (an overpainted photo) of an infant in a photographer’s studio, in a heavy gold frame. The photographer informs Jim the subject is Antonía’s child, the result of her pregnancy with Larry Donovan, who abandoned her. While the photographer dismisses the child as “too bad!”, he says Antonía is nonetheless “proud of the baby” and “wouldn’t hear of a cheap frame for the picture.” As Jim puts it:
Another girl would have kept her baby out of sight, but Tony, of course, must have its picture on exhibition at the town photographer’s, in a great gilt frame. How like her!
Of course it’s like her — it’s anti-performative. Antonía doesn’t display her child’s photo to challenge the townspeople’s notions of female sexuality and propriety. That’s beyond her — she’s incapable of using people, let alone her own baby, as props or devices. She displays her child’s photo proudly — even though the child’s existence forces her to suffer social sanction — because it could never cross her mind to do otherwise. A life force will never be ashamed of bringing forth life; the fulfillment of its purpose is always cause for celebration.
Lena and Tiny: Anti-Performative Independence
Other female characters in My Antonía also stay true to themselves without a hint of performatism . Lena Lindgard, for instance, tells Jim she has no intention of marrying: “Men are all right for friends, but as soon as you marry them they turn into cranky old fathers . . . I prefer to be foolish when I feel like it, and accountable to nobody.”
Lena fulfills that intention, becoming a dressmaker and, on the advice of Tiny Soderall, moving to San Francisco to open her own shop. As with Antonía, however, Cather doesn’t sugar-coat the cost of Lena’s choices. Lena understands the power of her beauty and enjoys using it for male attention, but there’s a price: people talk. As Tiny tells Jim, in a smaller town Lena “would always be gossiped about”; the move to San Francisco is both an opportunity and an escape into the anonymity of city life. And while Tiny attests that Lena “never gets any older,” this occurs towards the end of the novel, when Jim and Tiny meet up as adults after many years apart. The bittersweet, unstated truth is that, no matter how youthful Lena’s spirit, she is older (and, as Jim wryly notes, “a trifle too plump”). The reader can’t help but wonder how much longer she can be “careless” with men’s affections.
As for Tiny, she surprises everyone by moving to Alaska, running a hotel for gold miners, and ultimately buying and selling claims. When Jim meets her in San Francisco she is a wealthy businesswoman who professes few interests save for “making money.” Her adherence to her enterprising nature is unusual for the time, but again, Cather doesn’t sugar-coat the cost. The challenges of the Klondike Gold Rush have made Tiny “hard-faced” and taken three of her toes due to frostbite. Cather suggests this physical numbing extended to Tiny’s interior life, with Jim noting, “she was satisfied with her success but not elated. She was like someone in whom the faculty of becoming interested is worn out.”
Tiny lives on her own terms, prioritizing singlehood and material gain. There’s a good argument that Jim’s portrayal of her as “hard” and internally dulled is unreliable, that the other women from his childhood can’t help but fall short when compared to his romanticized Antonía. But the countervailing argument is that Jim sees Tiny clearly because, like Tiny, he’s also alone, effectively separated from his wife. Like Tiny, he’s chosen to dedicate his life to business. As such, I read his assessment of Tiny as rooted in the experience of a fellow traveler, rather than as clouded by nostalgia.
The Meaning of Empowerment
Given Jim’s near-reverence for Antonía, it’s reasonable to ask: Why the heck did he choose Genevieve as his wife? Why adore Antonía’s forthrightness and total lack of guile, then marry a grandstanding poser instead? Why extol Antonía’s creativity and productivity when your own spouse can only give money to others to create and produce (and “mediocre” art, at that)?
It’s a peculiar wrinkle Cather never quite resolves, but she does drop hints.
Ever the realist, Cather gives Jim permission to describe the considerable limits of his childhood home, Black Hawk. In town, one’s associates and one’s behavior are carefully watched and circumscribed by social and religious norms. An adolescent Jim is forbidden to attend dances at the Fireman’s Hall because his grandparents don’t want him mixing with strangers. Bored out of his skull, he paces the streets at night, directing his resentment at the homes he passes:
The life that went on in them seemed to be made up of evasions and negations; shifts to save cooking, to save washing and cleaning, devices to propitiate the tongue of gossip. This guarded mode of existence was like living under a tyranny. Peoples’ speech, their voices, their very glances, became furtive and repressed. Every individual taste, every natural appetite, was bridled by caution.
Life in town is stifling, but the alternative — life on the farm — is physically punishing and fraught with risk; Cather makes clear that bad harvests and bad decisions bring many farmers to ruin. So Jim does what any intelligent young man with a romantic bent would do: he leaves, attending college with the support of his grandparents, who hope for an easier, more comfortable life for him.
Jim is empowered by pursuing his education and career ambitions, becoming a successful railroad attorney. His horizons are broadened and his mind is cultivated by new places, people, and experiences. And yet success outside of Black Hawk involves acquiring status markers in a way that’s often performative. Jim acquires a college degree and a law license. He acquires wealth representing the railroads — an interesting specialty, as it would certainly require Jim to buy farmland. Might Jim engage in a little performative bluffing and dissembling as part of negotiations? Might he feel a twinge of misgiving to be using his legal education to extract concessions from the kind of unmannered, plain-spoken people that formed his youth?
Given the foregoing, Jim’s marriage to Genevieve seems the natural progression of his credential-building. He’s struggling as an “obscure young lawyer” in New York, then makes a “brilliant marriage” to “the only daughter of a distinguished man.” While the narrator rationalizes that Genevieve married Jim in an impulsive act of “bravado”, he’s studiously silent about Jim’s motivations. Did Jim initially fall for Genevieve, or did he marry her simply as an entry ticket into upper class New York society? If the latter, it gives Jim’s memories of Antonía a painful cast, as if his idealization of her is partly the sublimation of a truth he can’t admit to himself: He could never marry her because — at least in the circles in which Jim now moves — she’s beneath him.
In contrast to Jim (and to Lena and Tiny, for that matter) Antonía’s empowerment is not acquisitive, but generative. She doesn’t compile credentials that will unlock social or financial benefits, she literally creates life: nurturing thin saplings into an abundant fruit orchard, nurturing her children into the strong men and women that will survive her and go on to establish their own families. She lives outside of and untouched by worldly status-markers, and so for a world-weary Jim, she’s Edenic.
A part of him wants to get back to that Garden, to cast off the burdens of Acquiring and Signaling and return to a state of Being (and really, don’t we all?). To my mind, Jim’s most important childhood memory, and in fact to the key to the whole novel, occurs at the very beginning, just after his move to Nebraska and just before his friendship with Antonía:
I was something that lay under the sun and felt it, like the pumpkins, and I did not want to be anything more. I was entirely happy. Perhaps we feel like that when we die and become a part of something entire, whether it is sun and air, or goodness and knowledge. At any rate, that is happiness; to be dissolved into something complete and great.
For Jim, Antonía represents that wonderful dissolution; by novel’s end, she has become the Land, become Nature, become Life itself. No small wonder, then, that he recollects her with such tenderness and awe.




Great to read you again, Johanna.
This novel is a great one and worthy of a reread sooner than later. That said, reading your comments, recalling my own from a few years back, I like Jim’s idealization-romanticization of Antonia and her purity of motherhood a bit less. It’s a sort of idol-making born of distance, which you allude to, his desire for a childhood idyl that somewhat diminishes the person beneath his gaze. It makes for great narration, as a man recounting his origins and their best, lost love, but it somewhat undersells Tony as an individual. I’ll chalk that against Jim rather than Cather, though - she’s the one who wrote him in a complex, debatable narrative vantage point.
Thank you for writing! I love it.
I couldn't find your historical image of her anywhere else. Where did you get it? It looks so clean and modern, I was shocked that it's an historical image!