Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kevin LaTorre's avatar

Great to read you again, Johanna.

This novel is a great one and worthy of a reread sooner than later. That said, reading your comments, recalling my own from a few years back, I like Jim’s idealization-romanticization of Antonia and her purity of motherhood a bit less. It’s a sort of idol-making born of distance, which you allude to, his desire for a childhood idyl that somewhat diminishes the person beneath his gaze. It makes for great narration, as a man recounting his origins and their best, lost love, but it somewhat undersells Tony as an individual. I’ll chalk that against Jim rather than Cather, though - she’s the one who wrote him in a complex, debatable narrative vantage point.

Tyler's avatar

Thank you for writing! I love it.

I couldn't find your historical image of her anywhere else. Where did you get it? It looks so clean and modern, I was shocked that it's an historical image!

9 more comments...

Ready for more?